RT @SalfordMH: @TomPettinger @drruthannharpur @EmilyWeisfeld @sue_haddon @JamesTitcombe Here's the paper, I think. https://t.co/dwQCNS6uC2
@TomPettinger @drruthannharpur @EmilyWeisfeld @sue_haddon @JamesTitcombe Here's the paper, I think. https://t.co/dwQCNS6uC2
“Single session individual debriefing did not prevent the onset of post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) nor reduce psychological distress, compared to control.” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2002 https://t.co/KBPrtwFKMp
@g_m_theo @Johnnyhoston_2 @papadimi Ούτε εσύ γνωρίζεις αυτά τα θέματα και αμφιβάλλω εάν τα γνωρίζει κι ο δήθεν "ψυχολόγος". Εδώ επιστημονική δημοσίευση λέει τα ακριβώς αντίθετα. Ούτε σωστή φιλοκυβερνητική προπαγάνδα δεν μπορείς να κάνεις αμόρφωτε. htt
This woman specialises in medical harms. Things that we in the past considered good for you when tested were shown to be the opposite. 🤷🏻♀️
💯
RT @mgtmccartney: traumatic events - highly distressing. was thought 'debriefing', a chance to talk would prevent post traumatic stress dis…
RT @tilbots: The psychological process of 'reliving trauma' or 'debriefing' has no known positive effects, and can add to the harm caused b…
RT @tilbots: The psychological process of 'reliving trauma' or 'debriefing' has no known positive effects, and can add to the harm caused b…
The psychological process of 'reliving trauma' or 'debriefing' has no known positive effects, and can add to the harm caused by the initial trauma https://t.co/ZHJXuTGjpt
This is really fascinating: debriefing after a traumatic event has been found to increase chance of PTSD, not decrease. I have found this instinctively and glad it is evidenced. For me, best treatment was helping others, keeping busy, doing worthwhile thi
RT @ClickingSeason: People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
RT @ClickingSeason: People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
RT @ClickingSeason: People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
Definitions: conspicuous medicine, waste , low-value intervention: not only ineffective, but potentially harmful.
Getting into groups and rehearsing those events was a rehearsal of the original trauma and as badly traumatizing as the first time. Befriend but don’t rehearse. https://t.co/6wtdgbsGs8
RT @ClickingSeason: People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
RT @ClickingSeason: People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
RT @mgtmccartney: traumatic events - highly distressing. was thought 'debriefing', a chance to talk would prevent post traumatic stress dis…
RT @ClickingSeason: People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
People have TRULY missed the psychological implications of this one
RT @Cererean: Is it true that playing Tetris in the aftermath of a traumatic event helps. Presuming it's been studied; did anything turn ou…
Is it true that playing Tetris in the aftermath of a traumatic event helps. Presuming it's been studied; did anything turn out well?
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
Therapy where issue I discussed and relived usually makes issue worse not better...it's just parasocial venting. This is intuitive result - focusing and reliving issue makes it more salient but the last cannot be "fixed". The only way back is going forwar
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @mgtmccartney: traumatic events - highly distressing. was thought 'debriefing', a chance to talk would prevent post traumatic stress dis…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
RT @m_k_daouda: What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s i…
What if “Keep calm and carry on” worked better than “let’s focus on a traumatic event and make it the centre of someone’s identity”?
a birth debrief is routinely suggested for women with birth trauma and I don't see how rehashing it helps. I honestly think I'd faint if i saw the midwife who hurt me again
RT @mgtmccartney: traumatic events - highly distressing. was thought 'debriefing', a chance to talk would prevent post traumatic stress dis…
@marion_mcnaught @nrthwds40 @bselwyn_ There's a Cochrane Review here https://t.co/Hk9Ozic0SF). @BABCP @Padesky has written about this: can you help with evidence?
Robin, can I file this with receiving a debrief after what someone else determines is an incident requiring it, actually increases chances of developing PTSD! https://t.co/ERPo77gqwi @chigrl "help" can sometimes mean CYA actions!
@JessicaXDiamond @HRB99531653 Some below are quite long & the evidence appears to be early 00's but I hope they help. The key seems to be first aid rather than formal 'debriefing' https://t.co/IabbBLvJtV https://t.co/7sNC41DEsG https://t.co/VASYGiAm
RT @TMcGreenberg: In case anyone is curious, here's a link to a Cochrane Review of Critical Incident Stress Debriefing & quote: "Compulsor…
In case anyone is curious, here's a link to a Cochrane Review of Critical Incident Stress Debriefing & quote: "Compulsory debriefing of victims of trauma should cease." Psychological debriefing for preventing post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) htt
@saltneytoffee On this precise topic I think this is most relevant https://t.co/Y13JsUTcKY
@DrNeenaJha @Zead_Said @Doc_AnneMarie It’s interesting we ask “how” something has its effect (adverse in the case of psych debriefing for PTSD). Maybe we don’t know “how” but just know it’s effect (like gen anaesthetic). ...effect of psych debriefing on P
RT @the_etheropian: I’ve seen a few discussions on here about supporting #COVID19 health workers that brought up psychological debriefing a…
used to be that many people living through a terrible disaster were routinely given counselling to debrief. seems like a caring and kind thing to offer, until controlled trials said didn't help and may actually be harmful. https://t.co/UE3uBvfmFO
@Ouakil8 Là ce n'est pas de l'expsotions classiques, ils posent une questions "What is the worse moment that come back in your mind ?" et Tetris 20 min, peut-être qu'il est surtout urgent de ne RIEN faire https://t.co/eqp5l2rL4N
Excited to review this article. I was conversing with a colleague about the efficacy to debriefings and the abstract of this article seem to support my thoughts on personal supports vs group-type debriefings.
I’ve seen a few discussions on here about supporting #COVID19 health workers that brought up psychological debriefing and I just want to be clear: Psychological debriefing is not effective, is not recommended, and may even be DETRIMENTAL to mental health.
RT @MaryAnnC_CCJS: Personal and peer support is often more important than formalized "debriefings" after critical incidents. It's the follo…
Personal and peer support is often more important than formalized "debriefings" after critical incidents. It's the followup for those who are vulnerable or seek additional support that resources need to be available for prevention and early intervention. h
@otorhinosaur Here is a Cochrane review https://t.co/3d1njo7aSk
Here again are some interesting resources regarding this topic: https://t.co/u6fGZiY71W https://t.co/KoZldor20U https://t.co/SxP3yoSWSs
@krismartens Beste @krismartens, we hebben zelf geen systematische review uitgevoerd naar het effect van debriefing maar andere studies (bv https://t.co/tVhRZ9ynAh en https://t.co/CRErdPe9SP) konden niet aantonen dat debriefing een gunstig effect heeft op
@absalomedia @ideirdre @iproposethis @shaunwarnock_sw @traceycm74 @NSWRFS Once again, stress levels is a very narrow metric. I am currently reading articles and sources but for a sample there is this, https://t.co/OFr5VeADnr
Has someone disproven this finding that debriefing does more harm than good when it comes to trauma and PTSD? https://t.co/0wdz5kviSZ
@Narkoseonkel @tvonw1 @Layer8Supporter https://t.co/pxtL9CyZhy und https://t.co/2iJ7Pn9smy. Aufgrund deren wurde Debriefing in GB eingestellt. Der Konzept war verlockend, da einfache Lösungen angeboten waren. Die waren aber, wie so oft,wirkungslos.
@jungundfreudlos Gute Folge! Nur eine kleine Anmerkung: Debriefing nach Trauma werden nicht empfohlen (und sind evtl. sogar schädlich). Cochrane Review: https://t.co/j75aIvSZNV
@coopesdetat @ketaminh @GongGasGirl @NeelaJan @inquisitiveGyn I was thinking of the analogous situation of PTSD where although it seems obvious that intervention would help, it didn't, and maybe harmed. https://t.co/w2sSZ43xo5
RT @AnderRetolaza: No hay Pruebas de que las Intervenciones Psicológicas Breves tras #Catástrofes sean Efectivas. El #Debriefing de una sol…
RT @AnderRetolaza: No hay Pruebas de que las Intervenciones Psicológicas Breves tras #Catástrofes sean Efectivas. El #Debriefing de una sol…
No hay Pruebas de que las Intervenciones Psicológicas Breves tras #Catástrofes sean Efectivas. El #Debriefing de una sola Sesión no es Recomendable https://t.co/jXtl9TuqjH
RT @RedfernRex: @EDPractitioner @TessaRDavis @georgemastoras I think this was the Cochrane review that started our conversation. Just about…
@EDPractitioner @TessaRDavis @georgemastoras I think this was the Cochrane review that started our conversation. Just about to board a flight will see what else I have when I land: https://t.co/T2Vp68GMlV
@JKM8984 @Keirnoth @DegenRolf @clairlemon @WesselyS "At one year one trial reported that there was a significantly increased risk of PTSD in those receiving debriefing (odds ratio 2.88 (1.11 to 7.53))odds ratio 95%)..no evidence that debriefing reduced gen
@nicolacullum Not good enough on lots & numbers too small! Eg only 1 for imputed analysis. I can instantly counter with this one: https://t.co/laloQkstzK
also research: https://t.co/bJXWUw4W7O https://t.co/Y4qDIWXARq but is conflicting: https://t.co/wxT8Sqa6MD https://t.co/q6WjPW9LjY
Significantly risk of PTSD in receiving debriefing...no evidence that psychological debriefing is useful...debriefing should cease... https://t.co/Gx9C62NPTe
@superoz83 @prehospit_al @dlbywater 2 papers suggesting counselling may not be best option https://t.co/6STt5EPmwQ https://t.co/GXgjsOR0ky
.@TonySalvatore45 @samaritans @BMJ_Open but overlap with 'debriefing' unclear https://t.co/CUF6VhFl0C @cochranecollab @WesselyS
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
RT @LDNtrauma: Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD…
Wessely: Phychological debriefing doesn’t help, may increase PTSD by interrupting how people normally cope. https://t.co/vAD9oOCnnN #LTC2015
.@BenDench Rose, Bisson & Churchill 2002 https://t.co/6o5zKcSg3D One off psychological debrief may cause harm #ParisAttacks
@robgpoole The continuation of post-trauma debriefing despite http://t.co/CcQbfEon0F demonstrates power of intuitive ideas over evidence.
@robgpoole The continuation of post-trauma debriefing despite http://t.co/CcQbfEon0F demonstrates power of intuitive ideas over evidence.